Office Hours
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking, Investment Services, Annuities
Would you like to create a personalized quote?
Maggie Dutton
Maggie Dutton Ins Agency Inc
Office Hours
Address
# 7
St Simons Island, GA 31522-1600
Office complex is Plantation Village. Enter onto Main St. from Demere Rd. Last building on right.
Office Hours
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking, Investment Services, Annuities
Would you like to create a personalized quote?
Office Info
Office Info
-
Phone
(912) 638-1881 -
Toll Free
(800) 990-9162 -
Fax
(912) 638-9902
Languages
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking, Investment Services, Annuities
Office Info
Office Info
-
Phone
(912) 638-1881 -
Toll Free
(800) 990-9162 -
Fax
(912) 638-9902
Languages
Simple Insights®
8 tips for finding pet care while on vacation
8 tips for finding pet care while on vacation
Planning to leave pets behind on vacation? Help ensure dogs and cats are covered with this list of vacation pet care options, from pet-sitting to boarding.
Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself
Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself
To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.
Airbag safety: Tips to help maximize airbag effectiveness
Airbag safety: Tips to help maximize airbag effectiveness
Airbag systems have saved thousands of lives. Learn tips to help keep your airbag system functioning properly and enhance your safety.
Social Media
Viewing team member 1 of 9
Carmen Battistini
Office Manager
License #770700
Carmen, our Office Manager, is a proud native of Uruguay and has been part of our team since 2006. She is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life, and Health insurance, and she focuses on supporting large apartment complexes with their coverage needs. Carmen speaks fluent Spanish and serves as a Notary Public, providing valuable assistance to our community. She is mom to a spirited rescue dog named Roy and enjoys life as a grandmother to four grandsons and a great‐grandson. In her spare time, she loves painting and has even shared some of her artwork that now hangs in our office.
Viewing team member 2 of 9
Anna Sauls
Account Representative
License #3663650
Anna joined our team after two years with another State Farm agent in Georgia. A Baxley native with lifelong ties to the Golden Isles, she and her husband are excited to return to the community with their 3‐year‐old son. When she’s not busy chasing Baylor, Anna enjoys running, working out, and exploring new local restaurants. She is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life, and Health insurance and is ready to assist with your auto and home insurance needs.
Viewing team member 3 of 9
Anita Callaway
Account Representative
License #2870323
Anita has been a valued member of Team Maggie Dutton for 14 years and previously worked with State Farm agents in both Ohio and Tennessee, giving her a total of 19 years in the State Farm family. She is licensed in Property and Casualty insurance and handles our large auto fleet policies. Anita has three daughters—including twins—and one son, but her greatest joy is being “Nina” to ten grandchildren. Her fur‐baby, Richie, patiently keeps up with all the excitement those grandkids bring.
Viewing team member 4 of 9
Sharon Proudfoot
Office Representative
License #2952438
Sharon joined our team in 2014 after 13 years with the American Cancer Society, bringing a deep passion for community involvement. She continually encourages our office to support meaningful causes and local organizations. Sharon is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life, and Health insurance and is dedicated to helping protect what matters most. Although she has no children of her own, she has proudly been “Ms. Sharon” to hundreds of kids throughout the Golden Isles community for more than 30 years. Outside the office, she enjoys performing on local stages, portraying characters ranging from Mrs. Cratchit to whimsical roles like a Mouse, Pig, Knight, or even a singing “sister.”
Viewing team member 5 of 9
Dylan Reyna
Account Representative
License #3583277
Dylan has been a valuable member of our team for more than two years, joining us after three years at Merrill Lynch. He grew up on St. Simons Island and graduated from Frederica Academy, where he played baseball for seven years, before earning his degree from Georgia Southern University. A passionate golfer, Dylan has scored four Holes‐in‐One—three of them at the Brunswick Country Club. He and his wife are excited new parents and share their home with their daughter and a sweet dog, Libby. Dylan is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life, and Health insurance.
Viewing team member 6 of 9
Laura Webb
Account Representative
License #3688567
Laura brings a wide‐ranging professional background to our team, from restaurant and retail management to owning her own roofing company—experience that gives her strong insight into property insurance needs. She has been married for over 20 years and has a son, two stepchildren, and two grandsons. Laura serves on the board of the Marty Lyons Foundation and is passionate about helping make dreams come true for terminally ill children. In her spare time, she enjoys traveling, fishing, and playing golf. Her golf team, “The Dirty Coconuts,” frequently places in local tournaments and participates in many charitable events. Laura is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life, and Health insurance.
Viewing team member 7 of 9
Nancy Allen
License #3141637
Nancy has been a valuable part of our team for two years, bringing more than 25 years of customer service experience. She works remotely and appreciates the balance it provides between serving customers and supporting her family. Nancy has been married for more than 30 years and has three adult sons, but her favorite title is “Gigi” to two grandsons. She enjoys spending time with family, reading, gardening, writing, and taking long walks.
Viewing team member 8 of 9
Sydney Zellner
License #3230789
Sydney joined our team in 2022 and has been part of the State Farm family since 2017. As a mom to three daughters who play soccer, she proudly embraces her role as a “soccer mom.” Family time is important to Sydney, whether they’re on the field or enjoying sports together. She and her husband enjoy playing golf, and Sydney also joins her daughters on the soccer field. Originally from Ft. Myers, Florida, she now happily calls Georgia home, especially with most of her family nearby.
Viewing team member 9 of 9
Julia Cieszeski
Receptionist
License #3859970
Julia is newly licensed in Property and Casualty insurance and has been a fresh, enthusiastic addition to our team since 2023. Often the first friendly face you see—or voice you hear—when you visit or call our office, she is ready to assist with your insurance inquiries. Julia grew up in Upstate New York before moving to St. Simons Island for her senior year at Glynn Academy. She later graduated from the College of Coastal Georgia with a degree in Public Management. She enjoys working with kids and is a sought‐after babysitter throughout the Golden Isles community. In her spare time, she enjoys watercolor painting, sewing, photography, and visits from her four‐legged nephew, Ian the Corgi.