Skip to content

State Farm® Insurance Agent Maggie Dutton

Maggie Dutton Ins Agency Inc

400 Main St
# 7
St Simons Island, GA 31522-1600

Office complex is Plantation Village. Enter onto Main St. from Demere Rd. Last building on right.

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Maggie Dutton

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info


400 Main St
# 7
St Simons Island, GA 31522-1600


English, Spanish

I’ve been a local agent in the Golden Isles of Georgia for 40 years and part of the St. Simons Island community for 42 years. My team and I have qualified for many State Farm and industry honors, including Chairman’s Circle, President’s Club, Ambassador Travel, and Million Dollar Round Table. We’re active in the Brunswick-Golden Isles Chamber of Commerce and love supporting our community – from sponsoring softball teams to supporting our local schools. We are proud to have been selected among the Top 100 agents nationwide for Outstanding Community Engagement, which helped us present a grant to a local deserving organization.

Together, my team and I have more than 100 years of State Farm experience. We’re bilingual and are able to support our Spanish-speaking neighbors. Call us for your car, boat, motorcycle, golf cart, or recreational vehicle insurance. Looking for homeowner, condo or renter insurance – we can help! We speak life insurance. And, as a fellow small business owner, I’d be honored to help you with your small business insurance needs. We’re located on St. Simons Island, but we also serve good neighbors in Brunswick, Darien, Eulonia, Ludowici, Waverly, Waynesville, and throughout Georgia! We are also licensed in Alabama, Florida, South Carolina, and North Carolina.

PLEASE NOTE: Coastal guidelines apply for some policies.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Mutual Funds, Annuities

Skip Infinite Scroll Facebook Feed

We focus on Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Boatowner and Recreational Vehicle Insurance, and Life Insurance on St. Simons Island, in Brunswick, Darien, Eulonia, Waynesville, Waverly, and more. In a busy world, we believe that getting to know State Farm customers is the key to understanding and satisfying their needs. We pride ourselves on the ability to take the stress and worry out of insurance and planning for a bright future.

Meet my awesome Maggie Dutton State Farm Team! Combined, they have nearly 60 years experience with State Farm and are here to help make sure life goes right for you and your family.

We have one team member who speaks Spanish and is also a Notary Public. We love being involved in our community, and you'll find us out and about at events throughout the year.

Carmen Battistini State Farm Agent Team Member

Carmen Battistini

Office Manager

Carmen, our Office Manager, is a native of Uruguay. She joined our team in 2006 and is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life, and Health. She speaks fluent Spanish and is a Notary Public. She's mom to a spirited rescue named Roy, and has four human grandsons! In her spare time, Carmen enjoys painting and has shared a few with us to hang in the office!

Anita Callaway State Farm Agent Team Member

Anita Callaway

Account Representative

Anita has been part of Team Maggie Dutton for 10 years. She worked for other agents in Ohio and Tennessee, for a total of 15 years in the State Farm family. She's licensed in Property and Casualty. Anita has three daughters (including twins) and one son, but is most proud to be "Nina" to TEN grandchildren! She has one fur-baby, Richie, who is very patient with all of those grandchildren.

Terri Schott State Farm Agent Team Member

Terri Schott

Account Representative

Terri joined our team in 2017, after working 10 years with State Farm agents in Maryland and Missouri. She's licensed in Property, Casualty, Life, and Health. Terri is mom to three daughters who live in MO, IL, and OH, and welcomed her grandson Rowen in 2022! Her youngest daughter Grace, interned in our office and worked as an agent team member in metro St. Louis while attending St. Louis University. Terri has two four-legged kids still at home, Harper and Hugo, and loves volunteering with the Humane Society of South Coastal Georgia.

Sharon Proudfoot State Farm Agent Team Member

Sharon Proudfoot

Office Representative

Sharon joined our team in 2014, after 13 years with the American Cancer Society. She's always getting us involved in supporting great causes and local organizations. Sharon is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life, and Health. She has no children of her own, but has been "Ms. Sharon" to hundreds of kids throughout the community for more than 30 years! You might find her on a local stage in the Golden Isles, portraying anyone from Mrs. Cratchit to a Mouse/Pig/Knight, or even a singing "sister"!

Dylan Reyna State Farm Agent Team Member

Dylan Reyna

Account Representative

Dylan is our newest team member and joins us after three years at Merrill Lynch. He grew up on St. Simons Island and graduated from Frederica Academy, where he played baseball for seven years. He's a graduate of Georgia Southern University. Dylan loves playing golf and has scored FOUR Holes-in-One, three of them at the Brunswick Country Club! He has a sweet dog named Libby, but is most excited to be getting married this coming October.

Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.